A House Divided Against Itself

“Can two walk together, except they be agreed?” (Amos 3:3).

AI, Healthcare, Israel, and the Fight Over the First Black Speaker

On November 3, I sat at my post as a poll worker and watched my neighbors come in one by one to cast their ballots. By the next morning the whole country knew what they had done. Democrats swept the midterms. When the new Congress convenes in January, they will hold more than 250 seats in the House and control of the Senate, a victory so large it reached into places many people thought Democrats would never win again. In any other year you would expect a parade. Instead, two weeks later, the party is at war, and the fight is among Democrats themselves. The left wing is lined up against the center, and the divide has become so severe that serious people are asking whether the party can agree on who should lead it, much less what it should do with the power voters just handed it.

Even the people who make a living explaining the Democratic Party have noticed. Ezra Klein spent the week after the election building his podcast around the split. It was an unorthodox week for his show, and I think Klein knew it, because he opened his November 13 episode by explaining his theory. He wanted, he said, to invite on “different perspectives inside the Democratic coalition” to explore how Democrats won power and how they should now wield it. On Tuesday he hosted Adam Jentleson of the Searchlight Institute, “a more centrist perspective.” On Friday, from the left, he hosted Hasan Piker, a Twitch streamer who had “become something of a major character in this election.” Piker stumped with DSA candidates, stood beside Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan, was named by Benjamin Netanyahu in his address to the United Nations, and even appeared on the Jumbotron at the Republicans’ midterm convention in Dallas, in a photo of himself wearing nothing but his underwear. Republicans, Klein said, “tried to make him into the boogeyman of the election.” In other words, Klein staged the Democratic Party’s civil war as a two-part series, the center on Tuesday and the left on Friday. When I listened, I heard three issues that could bring the whole house down: artificial intelligence, healthcare and Israel.

The prophet Amos asked a question that seems particularly appropriate for Democrats today: “Can two walk together, except they be agreed?” (Amos 3:3). The Democratic Party has succeeded in winning elections. But winning together and governing together are not necessarily the same thing. The question now is whether Democrats can agree on enough to move forward, or whether their internal divisions will prevent them from exercising the very power voters entrusted to them.

That word, boogeyman, stayed with me, because I have been thinking about bogeymen all month. Every election season a party needs a monster to frighten its voters home, and this year Republicans dressed a streamer in the costume. But the greatest danger to this new Democratic majority lives inside its own caucus.

Take something like artificial intelligence. Everyone wants to use AI and yet discussion of data centers creates a three-way split. One wing wants a moratorium on new data centers, another wants to tax them, and a third wants federal rules. But for those of us who still go to work in corporate America every day, AI is more than a policy debate. We are watching it move into the departments where we built our careers, and we know that losing a job in this country costs far more than a paycheck.

Which brings me to the next divide. Healthcare. In America, health insurance is tied to our job. About half of all Americans get their coverage through an employer, so when a worker fears for her position, she is also fearing for her doctor, her prescriptions and her family’s care. Her first question is what will happen to her healthcare, and this year the answer is grim. The enhanced Affordable Care Act tax credits expired at the end of 2025, and according to KFF, what people paid in premiums after tax credits rose 114 percent, more than $1,000 a year, just to stay in the same plan. Average deductibles on marketplace plans rose 37 percent.

When Klein and Piker turned to healthcare, Piker called single-payer “the only solution.” Klein asked him about Vermont, the one state that tried to build single-payer with full Democratic control and watched it collapse, and Piker admitted he was not familiar with it. He conceded that doing it all at once is not “feasible or possible right now” and called Medicare for All the party’s “legislative North Star.” Klein predicted the party would settle on a “Medicare-for-more synthesis.” Piker rejected that middle road, saying that if Democrats have to fight the insurance industry anyway, “we might as well go all the way.” And with only two years before voters return to the polls, it is hard to see how any of these plans could be passed and put in place.

So here is a party that just won both chambers, and its left and its center cannot agree whether to keep patching the marketplace or to tear down the entire system. Piker even faulted Kamala Harris for offering nothing “beyond just subsidizing the existing marketplace.” Let me be clear about where I stand. I do not support the Affordable Care Act. It was sold as protection for people who cannot afford healthcare, and then it sorted them by what they can pay. Its plans come in metal tiers, bronze, silver, gold and platinum. A bronze plan is designed to cover only about 60 percent of a typical enrollee’s medical costs, while a platinum plan covers about 90 percent, so the people with the least money are steered toward the plans that leave them paying the most when they actually get sick. The system has also proven easy to abuse. According to the Government Accountability Office, confirmed complaints of unauthorized enrollments and plan switches, many tied to brokers, rose from 66,548 in 2023 to 299,604 in 2025. This summer federal regulators canceled about 315,000 enrollments covering more than 760,000 people after finding they were unauthorized.

Klein, to his credit, named the problem nobody sees. “A huge amount of my health care spend is covered by an employer,” he said. “I don’t see it.” The worker who opens a COBRA letter sees all of it in one afternoon. What she needs is a system where coverage continues when a job ends, where everyone receives the same level of care regardless of income, and where only the contribution changes: those who earn more pay more, and those who earn less pay less. That is the principle God gave the children of Israel when He fed them manna in the wilderness: “he that gathered much had nothing over, and he that gathered little had no lack” (Exodus 16:18). But a reform like that requires a party willing to agree on something smaller than its slogans.

Then there is Israel, the issue Klein himself said “has the most possibility of tearing this coalition apart.” Klein played a clip of Piker telling Rashida Tlaib that calling yourself a liberal Zionist is “like saying you’re a liberal Nazi.” When Klein pressed him, Piker did not back away. “I do believe that Zionism is fascist,” he said. And when Piker wanted to describe Jewish voters in Michigan who would not support El-Sayed, he reached for American Black history. Canvassing their neighborhood, he said, was the equivalent of going to a “K.K.K. neighborhood to stump for like a Black candidate.” The terror our grandparents lived through became his metaphor for someone else’s cause. He did not recognize that the Klan lynched American Blacks and burned down their homes and communities. There is no comparison. The idea that Jewish voters in Michigan who support Israel are akin to the KKK was more than wrong and insensitive. It was nonsensical, almost mad. Yet this is the rhetoric now living inside the Democratic coalition, and Israel is the issue at the center of the fight over the first Black Speaker of the House.

The fight over the speakership may never become a real contest, and yet it reveals something about the hypocrisy at the heart of the Democratic Party. The party uses the American Black story as its foundation for calling every Republican a racist, while it ignores the obvious racism in its own house. During campaign elections they come into our communities and step into our churches to garner our votes. And yet Hakeem Jeffries, an American Black man born and raised in Brooklyn, is poised to become the first Black speaker in American history and he is being attacked by candidates that relied upon our votes to win their elections. The attacks began almost before the votes were counted. A Change.org petition demanding a new speaker passed one million signatures. Representative-elect Don Leonard of Ohio said he would be “shopping for a new leader” unless Jeffries changed his pro-Israel positions, and he conditioned his vote on ending U.S. support for Israel and the war in Iran and on a constitutional amendment to overturn Citizens United. Leonard then said senior Democrats threatened to make his life “a living hell.” He admitted it “aches” his heart to potentially oppose the first Black speaker, but he said “Rome is burning.”

The clearest opposition came from Melat Kiros of Colorado, a 29-year-old democratic socialist who said she would not vote for anyone in leadership who takes corporate PAC money. Accepting PAC support is legal, and the Supreme Court has repeatedly protected political spending as free speech. Yet here is an immigrant congresswoman, joined by a new class of progressives, suggesting that an American has no right to accept support from American PACs. Nevertheless, their standard rules out Jeffries, who is among the top recipients of pro-Israel PAC and individual contributions in Congress. The press celebrated Kiros as Colorado’s first Black congresswoman. She was born in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, and came to Denver as a baby after her father won the diversity visa lottery. I wish her and her family well. But this is exactly why I insist on the distinction between Black and American Black. Black is a global category. American Black means the descendants of the people who were slaves on this soil. Under the umbrella of “Black representation,” an immigrant congresswoman is counted as a historic first, and in her first weeks she is lining up against the first American Black man positioned to hold the gavel.

I will not pretend the resistance comes only from immigrants, because accountability has to start at home. Chris Rabb of Philadelphia, a descendant of Black freedom fighters and abolitionists, has also refused to commit to Jeffries. In his primary, the other two major candidates, both Black, said they would support Jeffries. State Senator Sharif Street put it plainly: “As a Black man, I’d be proud to vote for Hakeem Jeffries.” Now look at who chose Rabb. He won 60 percent of the vote in majority-white precincts and only 28 percent in majority-Black precincts, the fewest of the three major candidates. The progressive movement has learned to elevate Black faces who carry its agenda, but in that district the Black neighborhoods wanted someone who would stand with Jeffries. Meanwhile, members of the Congressional Black Caucus have made their support for him clear.

The charge against Jeffries is about money: AIPAC money, pro-Israel money, corporate money. Fine. Then apply the standard evenly. The Unity & Justice Fund, a super PAC tied to CAIR’s advocacy arm, CAIR Action, gave $175,000 to the largest outside group supporting Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan. It also gave at least $120,000 to a key PAC behind Zohran Mamdani’s run for mayor of New York. El-Sayed’s campaign collected more than $115,000 from people who work for CAIR or have held leadership roles there. A super PAC called American Priorities spent more than $6 million electing candidates who oppose AIPAC. CAIR says it has never donated to any campaign or PAC, and none of this money has been shown to be illegal. Neither is AIPAC’s. My question is about consistency. If money from a lobby that supports Israel disqualifies the first Black speaker, why does money organized around the opposite side of the same conflict count as grassroots? The purity test only seems to be given to one man.

American Black Democratic voters did their part. They stood in line in November, as they always do, for a Democratic coalition that now includes more immigrants and children of immigrants than ever before: Mamdani, born in Uganda, leading New York City; El-Sayed, whose father emigrated from Egypt, headed to the Senate; Kiros, born in Ethiopia, headed to the House. American blacks were asked to celebrate their stories as American stories, and many of them do. But what is the response? The first American Black man in line for the speaker’s gavel is told that his position on Israel makes him unworthy, by a movement that elected its own champions with money tied to the other side of that very conflict.

The Senate looks no different. Chuck Schumer led his party into the majority and may not keep his job. Bernie Sanders and Senator Elissa Slotkin of Michigan, who is no progressive, both say they will not back him, and progressive groups are working to draft Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, who says there “should be no coronation.” Piker told Klein he wants Van Hollen too. “Well, I’m pragmatic,” he said. Some of the anger at Schumer is about his age and his votes, but progressive critics also call him a servant of “Israel-right-or-wrong policies.” The thread tying the House and Senate rebellions together is Israel.

The same purity test is being given far beyond Congress. In October, Stephen A. Smith accepted an invitation to dinner at the White House with President Trump, Bill Maher and Kid Rock. By Kid Rock’s account, the conversation ranged from socialism and the war in Iran to unemployment among Black women and HBCUs. You would think an American Black man raising the jobs of Black women and the future of our colleges at the president’s table would be welcomed by the people who claim to speak for us. Instead he was treated as if he had committed a sin so great there was no way to redeem him. D.L. Hughley asked why Trump “feels so comfortable talking to you,” and Smith was accused of selling out. Smith fired back at his critics: “What the f--- are you doing? Have you done anything?” He said he was tired of people complaining about what our community needs, and then calling it selling out “when somebody is actually trying to take steps to do something about it.”

Then, a week after the election, Smith sat down with Trump for a 40-minute interview at the White House, and he did not go easy on him. He asked him directly what happened. When Trump insisted he was not on the ballot, Smith reminded him that he had told Americans to vote as if he were. When Trump bragged about his popularity, Smith told him, “Your approval rating is lower than the Democrats.” That is what accountability across the aisle looks like. And afterward, Smith warned Democrats about the very thing I am describing. “Now they will tell you they’re a very big tent and there’s room for everybody,” he said, “but I think that the progressive left has shown you there isn’t room for everybody.” If you are not willing to accept their beliefs “100%,” he said, “then they got a problem with you.”

When others discussed the interview, they made fun of the fact that Donald Trump could name only a few things he had done specifically for American Blacks, while everything else he claimed was for all Americans. They were not satisfied with what Trump had done for us specifically, and yet they supported Barack Obama, who made it plain that he was not going to do anything specifically for the American Black community. “I’m not the president of black America,” he said in 2012. “I’m the president of the United States of America.” And he did not. They supported Kamala Harris, whose agenda for “Black men” never named the descendants of American slavery. When theGrio asked her about reparations in 2019, she pointed to a tax credit for all families earning up to $100,000 and said, “any policy that will benefit black people, will benefit all of society.” In other words, she had no intention of doing anything for the American Black community alone. And yet American Blacks gave both of them overwhelming support. It is clear that American Blacks who continue to vote Democrat are blind, and they complicitly give away their power one election at a time.

I remember when the morning after an election meant the winners and the losers at least would announce they were ready to work together, even when nobody fully believed it. This year I have heard very little of that. What I have witnessed instead is contempt, a deep and visceral disdain for anyone who would dare to sit at the same table as the president, or even suggest they might lean in his direction. Bill Maher was punished for it. Stephen A. Smith was punished for it. Even Jeffries has been criticized by progressives for a private August meeting with Jared Kushner. In this climate, a conversation is treated as a betrayal.

The calendar is short. House Democrats hold leadership elections November 18 and 19. Senate Democrats elect their leaders by secret ballot in early December. The full House elects its speaker on January 3. Jeffries remains the overwhelming favorite, and so far no one has stepped forward to run against him. But winning a gavel and governing with it are two different things. A party that cannot agree whether to halt data centers or tax them, whether to patch the ACA or replace it, and whether a liberal Zionist is a colleague or a Nazi will struggle to pass its own legislation.

And that struggle is a gift to Republicans. They lost badly, and they know it. But the president still holds the veto pen, and Democrats, with more than 250 seats, are far short of the 290 votes it takes to override him in the House. Whatever a divided Democratic caucus manages to pass can be stopped at the president’s desk, and every veto becomes a Republican talking point: Democrats won power and delivered nothing. While Democrats spend the next two years purifying their ranks, Republicans will be adjusting to the new order, studying what voters punished them for, and building their case for 2028. None of this has to be depressing, but it should be instructive. A party that treats a conversation as a sin will have a hard time building the coalition it needs to govern.

When the scribes accused Jesus of casting out devils by the power of the devil, He answered them with a principle every politician should memorize: “And if a house be divided against itself, that house cannot stand” (Mark 3:25). The Democrats now hold the House. The question is whether they can stand in it. And as an American Black woman who worked the polls on November 3, I have one more question. American Black Democrats got what they wanted. They lined up behind candidates whose families arrived a generation ago, and they were glad to welcome them. Now the first American Black man to reach the speaker’s chair is being treated as the problem. If this house is divided, I want to know which room they have set aside for any American Black, and whether this new generation of Democrats will close the door to every one of them.


 

Jacqueline Session Ausby

Jacqueline Session Ausby currently lives in New Jersey and works in Philadelphia.  She is a fiction writer that enjoys spending her time writing about flawed characters.  If she's not writing, she's spending time with family. 

Next
Next

Who Gets to Be the Victim?